The sanctity of contract, and the central obligation under common law to honour one's obligations, is critical to commercial certainty; and the rule of law.  Pacta sunt servanda - the legal maxim that agreements must be kept has its origins in the 13th century (Gregory IX Liber Extra, 1234), despite its Roman Law appearance.  Grotuis reinforced the concept as binding individuals and States alike (De Jure  Belli ac Paris, 1625).

For most commercial agreements, a relatively simple transaction for the sale of goods or other rights, the principle generally holds - the goods are transferred for value, and the courts will not intervene save in the case of fraud, public policy or misrepresentation.

That position changes where relationships are ongoing, and the surrounding circumstances change.  In gas supply, long term operation and maintenance, software and other technology development and construction projects, the contracts cover the description of the work or service to be carried out and the price.  Mostly.  

However, when the unexpected happens, the best efforts of contract draughters aside, contracts can be found wanting.  As Lord Neuberger commented in 2015, "... there is no principle of interpretation which entitles a court to re-write a contractual provision simply because a factor which the parties catered for does not seem to be developing in the way in which the parties may well have expected." (Arnold v Britton [2015] UKSC 35 at [41]). 

When most commercial activity was severely interrupted during covid, few if any contracts catered for the disruption.  The change in law provisions were found wanting, and a pandemic hadn't been considered when most contracts had been drafted.  Similarly, the more recent increase in diesel prices following the closure of the Straits of Hormuz did not, save in rare cases, trigger a right to increase prices under any contract (other than at the pump).

The courts do offer some assistance where a particular reading of a contractual term makes commercial sense in the wider context of when it was agreed (Firm P1 v Zurich Australian Insurance [2014] NZSC 147 and Bathurst Resources v L & M Coal Holdings [2021] NZSC 85).  However, that approach does not extend to the courts overriding clear commercial terms or to re-writing the contract to cover what might not have been anticipated.

Contracts do try to provide for such events, with rights to claim for the unforeseen in certain events, provision for variations, excusing performance for force majeure and, in the final event, cancellation for frustration (under the Contract and Commercial Law Act 2017).  There is no procedure, though, to amend contractual terms to preserve what had been agreed at the time the contract was entered into.

This becomes a matter for negotiation, often little more than a Hail Mary entreaty.

At civil law, the concept of clausula rebus sic stantibus is implied into every contract, meaning "things standing thus".  Or in the fuller mediaeval form, contractus qui habent tractum successivum et dependentiam de futuro rebus sic stantibus intelliguntur - contracts with continuing performance that depends on the future are understood to bind only while circumstances stay as they were.

In practice, a fundamental change, which is unforeseen and which radically transforms the obligations still to be performed under a contract, may be used to amend the contract terms to preserve what had originally been agreed in essence.  The additional diesel price would be passed on.

While appearing to open to door to radical interference in the sanctity of contract, the doctrine applies only in exceptional cases (in the international law case of Gabčíkovo-Nagymaros Project (Hungary/Slovakia), ICJ 1997, concerning a dam over the River Danube, Hungary’s arguments based on political change, economic non-viability and new environmental knowledge all failed to persuade the ICJ that the relevant treaty between Hungary and the Czech Republic should be amended under the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties).

In New Zealand, taking the recent increase in fuel prices as an example, at the time that a contract has been entered into, it is unlikely that the impact on project costs would have been considered, or that the owner/client would have considered fuel price fluctuations.  A 40% cost increase in meeting contractual obligations would not be, in many cases, sustainable.  Certainly, any contractor caught in that situation would be forgiven for reducing other costs where possible and making claims under more productive heads.

The law would not help, other than raising the prospect of impossibility and termination for frustration or breach.  At common law, the agreement made at the time the contract was entered into must be preserved, regardless of how unfair or uncommercial it may have become.  The courts will endeavour to fill the gaps or clarify ambiguity by implying terms consistent with what had been intended, but that is as far as it will go, short of cancelling the contract for impossibility or breach.

The cost and disruption of termination (and legal costs in fighting it) should not be under estimated.  In that context, most relationship contracts, and particularly construction contracts, provide a framework for future uncertainty.  Where that framework falls down, owners are left with the option of either forcing reluctant, and frequently financially impossible performance or finding another contractor/supplier.

At civil law, the courts are more willing to review unanticipated events in the context of the overall agreement, and to amend specific commercial terms to preserve the core of the original transaction, applying the maxim of rebus sic stantibus.

When balancing contract enforcement against its consequences and the desire to achieve a successful project outcome, in lieu of such an approach under common law, there is much to be said for having a sensible and pragmatic discussion over increased costs and mitigation.  The practicality is that it is cheaper to pay the existing contractor to stay on site, albeit on amended terms, than the alternatives that the common law provide.

A good mediator will explain this in a way which all parties should be able to accept.

Arrow Left Return to All